In a recent performance test of the most popular voice assistants on the market by YouTuber MKBHD, Google Assistant emerged as the best voice assistant, outperforming Apple’s Siri, Samsung’s Bixby, and Amazon’s Alexa. Google’s voice assistant relies on Google’s computing power and an impressive amount of data that the company collects about its users. The comparisons showed that Google Assistant and Samsung Bixby have “the most control over a user’s device”. This includes the ability to interact with apps, take a photo, start a voice recording, and more.
Digital voice assistants have evolved over time and can now take on a lot of advanced tasks rather than just answering your weather questions and doing basic conversions. Over the past few years, Google Assistant has been considered the best voice assistant on a smartphone, primarily when it comes to accuracy and overall functionality. And it’s no big surprise, since Google Assistant has full access to Google’s deep knowledge and extensive models that the company uses to train its AI.
They’ve gotten a little less attention over the past year than in years past, but it’s still fun to see how they all compare to how we actually use them. In a comparison conducted this week, YouTuber MKBHD pitted Google Assistant against Apple’s Siri, Samsung’s Bixby, and Amazon’s Alexa, and of course Assistant came out on top. Several reasons can explain this. First, Assistant relies on Google’s powerful artificial intelligence to help it understand and accurately interpret user requests.
Second, Google Assistant has access to a large amount of data from its users, which allows it to provide a more personalized experience. The company also collects data from various services such as search, maps and email to improve the functionality and performance of Google Assistant. However, one of the main reasons for Google Assistant’s victory is its strong conversational ability. Google’s AI uses powerful NLP (natural language processing) algorithms to understand the meaning and context of words and sentences.
Apple’s Siri took second place in the competition. He did well when asked to perform tasks such as setting a timer and searching the Internet, but struggled when asked to answer more complex questions or conversation. Additionally, Siri was unable to perform tasks that required interaction with apps. Bixby, on the other hand, came in third and has the highest marks in device control. Samsung’s Bixby has excelled in device control thanks to its integration with Samsung devices.
This allows Bixby to control system settings and integrate more deeply with apps than any other voice assistant. It can send text messages, check sports scores, dim the screen, check your calendar, launch apps and more. However, for some reason, Apple’s Siri cannot set more than one timer, which Bixby can easily do. In terms of integration, Google Assistant comes second only to Bixby with support for searching your own photos and the ability to start playing a TV show on Netflix.
Of all the voice assistants, Amazon’s Alexa did the worst in the test. This is due to several factors. First of all, Amazon Alexa isn’t built into smartphones, which means it doesn’t have the personal touch of other voice assistants. This can make it less intuitive and less convenient. Then Alexa’s inaccuracy in finding facts, inability to interact with other apps, and poor conversational patterns combine to create a poor experience when used on a phone. These issues make it difficult for Alexa to provide useful and reliable information.
This is a key expectation for voice assistants. Likewise, the inclusion of Amazon advertisements between tasks can be annoying and disrupt the user experience. Even though Google Assistant has been crowned the champion, it really comes down to which ecosystem you’re most comfortable and invested in. In other words, your smart home can have a lot of weight in influencing which assistant you want to use. Google Assistant is the most available, but if you’ve invested heavily in Alexa Smart Home or Apple HomeKit, you might want to choose something else.
Furthermore, these devices are known to have a long list of privacy issues. In order to offer a practical voice assistant, Google actually relies on an impressive amount of data that it collects about its users with most of these products. A series of new complaints in 2021 accused Siri, Alexa and Google Assistant of recording users’ private conversations without their consent. These assistants listen to and record conversations even when they are not being questioned. Normally, they should be activated when prompted. For example, when you say “Hey Siri”.
A study released earlier this year found that Amazon uses voice data collected by Echo-connected speakers to serve targeted ads. Researchers found that Amazon processes voice data to infer users’ interests and uses it to display targeted ads on speakers and across the web. Interaction with connected speakers would result in up to 30 times higher bids from advertisers. Finally, the researchers found that Amazon’s and Skills’ operational practices often conflict with their privacy policies.
What is your opinion on the subject?
What do you think of YouTuber MKBHD’s comparison test?
What do you think of Google Assistant’s top ranking?
Do you think we should invite these devices into our homes?
In your opinion, do these devices really make life easier for users?
Complaints Accuse Siri, Alexa and Google of Eavesdropping When They Shouldn’t, Apple Faces Siri Privacy Lawsuit
Amazon uses voice data collected by Echo-connected speakers to show targeted advertising, study finds
Third parties listen to what you tell Google Home about what to improve AI, Google says
Ring security camera user files class action lawsuit against Amazon after hacker accessed camera to see and talk to his underage children